Classical-Mechanics ยท Unit 10 ยท Video 3 ยท Interactive Practice

The Reciprocal Tail: Velocity Decay Under High-Speed Quadratic Drag

IKey Formulas

FormulaNameWhat you need
mdvdt=โˆ’ฮฒv2m\dfrac{dv}{dt} = -\beta v^2Equation of motion (quadratic drag)Mass mm, drag coefficient ฮฒ\beta
ฮฒ=12CDAฯ\beta = \tfrac{1}{2} C_D A \rhoDrag coefficientShape CDC_D, area AA, density ฯ\rho
v(t)=v01+t/ฯ„v(t) = \dfrac{v_0}{1 + t/\tau}Velocity (reciprocal decay)Launch speed v0v_0, time constant ฯ„\tau
ฯ„=mฮฒv0\tau = \dfrac{m}{\beta v_0}Time constantmm, ฮฒ\beta, v0v_0

Key Insight: The force law dictates the decay law โ€” squaring the velocity in the drag turns exponential decay into a slower, lingering 1/t1/t reciprocal tail.

IIThe Time Constant Sets the Timescale

The time constant ฯ„=m/(ฮฒv0)\tau = m/(\beta v_0) carries the mass โ€” how does a heavier object reshape the decay?

IIITwo Fingerprints: Reciprocal vs Exponential

Early on the two decay laws look identical โ€” where do their tails part ways?

๐Ÿ’ก For tโ‰ซฯ„t \gg \tau the reciprocal law approaches vโ‰ˆv0โ€‰ฯ„tv \approx \dfrac{v_0\,\tau}{t} โ€” a 1/t1/t power-law tail โ€” while the exponential v0eโˆ’t/ฯ„v_0 e^{-t/\tau} is already vanishingly small.

IVPredict the Speed Deep in the Tail

Before computing: how much speed survives at t=3ฯ„=6t = 3\tau = 6 s, out in the tail?

VQuiz Questions

Problem 1 ยท Evaluate the Solution

Given: quadratic drag gives v(t)=v01+t/ฯ„v(t) = \dfrac{v_0}{1 + t/\tau} with v0=20v_0 = 20 m/s and ฯ„=2\tau = 2 s โ€” find vv at t=2t = 2 s.

โœ… Correct! At t=ฯ„t = \tau the denominator is 1+1=21 + 1 = 2, so the speed is exactly half of v0v_0.
โŒ Wrong decay law. 7.47.4 m/s is v0eโˆ’t/ฯ„v_0 e^{-t/\tau} โ€” that is the exponential (linear-drag) answer. Quadratic drag decays as 1/(1+t/ฯ„)1/(1+t/\tau).
โŒ Not quite. Substitute carefully: 1+t/ฯ„=1+2/2=21 + t/\tau = 1 + 2/2 = 2, not 1+t1 + t.
Show solution

Substitute t=2t = 2 s, ฯ„=2\tau = 2 s into the reciprocal solution:

v(2)=v01+t/ฯ„=201+22=202=10ย m/sv(2) = \frac{v_0}{1 + t/\tau} = \frac{20}{1 + \tfrac{2}{2}} = \frac{20}{2} = 10\ \text{m/s}

At exactly one time constant the speed has dropped to v0/2v_0/2. (An exponential would give 20โ€‰eโˆ’1โ‰ˆ7.420\,e^{-1} \approx 7.4 m/s โ€” it plunges faster.)

Problem 2 ยท Does Mass Cancel?

Given: two projectiles fired with the same v0v_0 into the same fluid (same ฮฒ\beta). Projectile A has twice the mass of projectile B โ€” which slows more gradually?

โœ… Correct! ฯ„โˆm\tau \propto m, so ฯ„A=2ฯ„B\tau_A = 2\tau_B; a larger time constant stretches v(t)=v0/(1+t/ฯ„)v(t) = v_0/(1+t/\tau) into a gentler decay.
โŒ Mass does not cancel. Dividing mโ€‰dvdt=โˆ’ฮฒv2m\,\dfrac{dv}{dt} = -\beta v^2 by mm gives dvdt=โˆ’ฮฒmv2\dfrac{dv}{dt} = -\dfrac{\beta}{m}v^2 โ€” the mass sets the deceleration and survives inside ฯ„=m/(ฮฒv0)\tau = m/(\beta v_0).
โŒ Not quite. Compare the time constants: ฯ„=m/(ฮฒv0)\tau = m/(\beta v_0) grows with mass, and a larger ฯ„\tau means slower decay.
Show solution

The time constant is ฯ„=mฮฒv0\tau = \dfrac{m}{\beta v_0}. With v0v_0 and ฮฒ\beta fixed, ฯ„\tau is proportional to mass:

ฯ„Aฯ„B=mAmB=2\frac{\tau_A}{\tau_B} = \frac{m_A}{m_B} = 2

Since v(t)=v0/(1+t/ฯ„)v(t) = v_0/(1 + t/\tau) decays more slowly for larger ฯ„\tau, the heavier projectile A slows more gradually. Physically, both feel the same drag force at a given speed, but A's larger inertia resists the deceleration.

Problem 3 ยท From Constants to a Time

Given: m=4m = 4 kg, ฮฒ=0.05\beta = 0.05 kg/m, v0=20v_0 = 20 m/s, decaying as v(t)=v0/(1+t/ฯ„)v(t) = v_0/(1 + t/\tau) โ€” find ฯ„\tau, then the time when v=8v = 8 m/s.

What is the time constant ฯ„\tau?

At what time does v=8v = 8 m/s?

โœ… Correct! ฯ„=4\tau = 4 s, and inverting v(t)=8v(t) = 8 gives t=ฯ„โ€‰โฃ(v0vโˆ’1)=4(2.5โˆ’1)=6t = \tau\!\left(\tfrac{v_0}{v} - 1\right) = 4(2.5 - 1) = 6 s.
โŒ Check the time constant. ฯ„=mฮฒv0\tau = \dfrac{m}{\beta v_0} โ€” keep all three factors: dividing only by ฮฒ\beta gives 8080 s (you dropped v0v_0); inverting the ratio gives 0.250.25 s.
โŒ Check the time. Solve 201+t/ฯ„=8โ‡’1+t/ฯ„=2.5\dfrac{20}{1 + t/\tau} = 8 \Rightarrow 1 + t/\tau = 2.5. Don't drop the ฯ„\tau (t=ฯ„โ‹…1.5t = \tau \cdot 1.5), and don't forget the โˆ’1-1.
Show solution

Step 1 โ€” time constant:

ฯ„=mฮฒv0=4(0.05)(20)=41=4ย s\tau = \frac{m}{\beta v_0} = \frac{4}{(0.05)(20)} = \frac{4}{1} = 4\ \text{s}

Step 2 โ€” solve for the time at v=8v = 8 m/s:

201+t/ฯ„=8โ€…โ€Šโ‡’โ€…โ€Š1+t4=208=2.5โ€…โ€Šโ‡’โ€…โ€Št4=1.5โ€…โ€Šโ‡’โ€…โ€Št=6ย s\frac{20}{1 + t/\tau} = 8 \;\Rightarrow\; 1 + \frac{t}{4} = \frac{20}{8} = 2.5 \;\Rightarrow\; \frac{t}{4} = 1.5 \;\Rightarrow\; t = 6\ \text{s}

(An exponential would reach 88 m/s at t=ฯ„lnโก2.5โ‰ˆ3.7t = \tau\ln 2.5 \approx 3.7 s โ€” sooner, because it decays faster.)

Problem 4 ยท The Shape of the Tail

Given: v(t)=v01+t/ฯ„v(t) = \dfrac{v_0}{1 + t/\tau} โ€” at late times tโ‰ซฯ„t \gg \tau, how does the speed fall off?

โœ… Correct! For tโ‰ซฯ„t \gg \tau the 11 is negligible, so vโ‰ˆv0ฯ„/tv \approx v_0\tau/t โ€” a 1/t1/t power law, the long reciprocal tail.
โŒ That is the other law. eโˆ’t/ฯ„e^{-t/\tau} is the linear-drag fingerprint. Quadratic drag never gives an exponential โ€” its tail is the much slower 1/t1/t.
โŒ Not quite. Drop the 11 in 1+t/ฯ„1 + t/\tau for large tt: vโ‰ˆv0ฯ„/tv \approx v_0\tau/t, which decays as 1/t1/t (not 1/t21/t^2, and it does reach zero).
Show solution

For tโ‰ซฯ„t \gg \tau the constant term is dwarfed by t/ฯ„t/\tau:

v(t)=v01+t/ฯ„โ€…โ€Šโ†’โ€‰tโ‰ซฯ„โ€‰โ€…โ€Šv0t/ฯ„=v0โ€‰ฯ„tโ€…โ€Šโˆโ€…โ€Š1tv(t) = \frac{v_0}{1 + t/\tau} \;\xrightarrow{\,t \gg \tau\,}\; \frac{v_0}{t/\tau} = \frac{v_0\,\tau}{t} \;\propto\; \frac{1}{t}

The velocity decays as a 1/t1/t power law โ€” approaching zero but far more slowly than the exponential eโˆ’t/ฯ„e^{-t/\tau} of low-speed linear drag. This lingering 1/t1/t behavior is the "reciprocal tail."

Solved: 0 / 4