Incompressible flow: fluid created, removed, or neither
Key Insight: Divergence is the flux out of a tiny closed surface divided by the volume it encloses. Outward arrows alone do not make a source: v=(x๎ฑ^+y๎ท^โ)/(x2+y2) has โโ v=0 at every point except the origin.
IIVisualization 1 โ Divergence as Net Outflow from a Tiny Box
In a plane flow (vzโ=0), the net outflow through a small box's faces per unit area equals โโ v.
IIIVisualization 2 โ Outward Arrows Are Not Enough
Fluid created between two circles equals the difference of the flows across them; for speed 1/r that difference is zero.
IVVisualization 3 โ A Source in a Steady Downward Flow
A source of strength Q in a downward stream of speed U fills a rounded cap with its own fluid.
๐ก Q is the area of fluid the source creates per second, so far downstream that fluid, moving at speed U, fills a band of width Q/U.
VQuiz Questions
Problem 1 ยท Compute a Divergence
Given:v=3x๎ฑ^โy๎ท^โ+2zk^ โ findโโ v.
โ Correct!3+(โ1)+2=4, the same at every point, so every point is a source.
โ Close, butโฆ keep the sign: โvyโ/โy=โ(โy)/โy=โ1, not +1.
โ Not quite. The divergence is a scalar: the three partial derivatives are added, not listed as a vector.
โ Not quite. Differentiate each component with respect to its own variable: โvxโ/โx, โvyโ/โy, โvzโ/โz.
The divergence is zero everywhere, including at (1,1,0), so the point is neither a source nor a sink. Fluid pours in along the z-direction at exactly the rate it spreads out in x and y; the direction of the arrows in one plane cannot tell you this.
Problem 3 ยท Divergence at a Point
Given:v=x2y๎ฑ^+yz2๎ท^โ+xzk^ โ findโโ v at (1,โ2,3) and classify the point.
What is โโ v at (1,โ2,3)?
What is the point (1,โ2,3)?
โ Correct!โโ v=2xy+z2+x=โ4+9+1=6>0: a source.
โ Close, butโฆโ(x2y)/โx=2xy, not xy: the factor 2 was dropped.
โ Not quite. That sums โvxโ/โy+โvyโ/โz+โvzโ/โx. The divergence pairs each component with its own variable.
โ Not quite.2xy=2(1)(โ2)=โ4 is negative; keep its sign.
โ Check the divergence. Differentiate x2y in x, yz2 in y, xz in z, then substitute.
โ Check the classification. The sign of โโ v decides it: positive means fluid is created there.
Given: a flow spreads from the origin in all three dimensions, v=crnr^ with c>0, where r is the distance from the origin. Find the power n for which โโ v=0 at every point except the origin.
โ Correct! Speed โ1/r2 against sphere area 4ฯr2: the same flux crosses every sphere.
โ Close, butโฆ1/r is the answer in a plane, where a circle's length grows as r. A sphere's area grows as r2.
โ Not quite. At constant speed the flux 4ฯr2c grows with r, so fluid is created everywhere: โโ v=2c/r.
โ Not quite. Then the flux 4ฯc/r shrinks with r: fluid is removed everywhere, โโ v=โc/r4.
Show solution
The flux out through a sphere of radius r is speed times area:
ฮฆ(r)=crnโ 4ฯr2=4ฯcrn+2
No fluid is created between two spheres exactly when ฮฆ is the same for every r, so n+2=0, giving n=โ2. In components, v=c(x,y,z)/r3, and
โโ v=c(r33โโr53(x2+y2+z2)โ)=0(r๎ =0).
All the fluid is created at the origin, which is the only source.