Finance-Theory ยท Unit 7 ยท Video 1 ยท Interactive Practice

Ninety-Seven Cents a Share: How a Money-Fund Run Moved Treasury Bill Yields

IKey Formulas

FormulaNameWhat it says
P0,T=F(1+y)TP_{0,T} = \dfrac{F}{(1+y)^T}Bill price from its yieldFF is the face value and TT the years to maturity; a three-month bill has T=14T = \tfrac14, so at y=0.49%y = 0.49\% the price is 100(1.0049)1/4โ‰ˆ99.88\dfrac{100}{(1.0049)^{1/4}} \approx 99.88 per $100 of face value
(1+y)1/4โˆ’1(1+y)^{1/4} - 1Return over one quarterQuoted yields are annualized: (1.04)1/4โˆ’1โ‰ˆ0.985%(1.04)^{1/4} - 1 \approx 0.985\%, just under 1%1\% a quarter, and (1.0049)1/4โˆ’1โ‰ˆ0.122%(1.0049)^{1/4} - 1 \approx 0.122\%, about 12 cents on $100
1(1+ฯ€)30\dfrac{1}{(1+\pi)^{30}}Purchasing power in 30 yearsฯ€\pi is the inflation rate; at an illustrative ฯ€=2.5%\pi = 2.5\%, 1(1.025)30โ‰ˆ0.48\dfrac{1}{(1.025)^{30}} \approx 0.48, so $1 paid in 30 years buys what about $0.48 buys today
1.00โˆ’0.97=0.03=3%1.00 - 0.97 = 0.03 = 3\%Breaking the buckA share priced at $0.97 returns 3 cents less on every dollar: $1,000 comes back as $970

Key Insight: A Treasury carries no nominal default risk, so its yield does not measure default. The bill yield recorded a panic: a run from prime money funds bid bill prices up and the yield down to 3 basis points. What a Treasury holder does risk is inflation and changes in interest rates.

IIPrice and Yield of a Three-Month Bill

A bill's price falls as its annualized yield rises: the move from 3 to 49 basis points cost about 11 cents per $100.

IIIThe Whole Curve Rose

From 17 to 24 September 2008 every maturity rose, and the 30-year rose least.

๐Ÿ’ก Part of the 30-year's 32 basis points can plausibly be read as an added inflation premium after the $700 billion asset-purchase plan, but since every shorter maturity rose more, the rise is no clean measure of expected inflation.

IVWhy Everyone Redeems at Once

When holdings are worth $0.97 a share, each share paid out at $1.00 leaves less for those still in.

๐Ÿ’ก The $0.97 is the Reserve Primary Fund's share value once its $785 million of Lehman commercial paper was valued at zero; the redemption path is an illustration, and the real fund soon froze withdrawals.

VQuiz Questions

Problem 1 ยท The 18 September Bill

Given: on 18 September 2008 the three-month bill yielded 2323 basis points, annualized. Find the price of a bill with $100 of face value, using P0,T=F(1+y)TP_{0,T} = \dfrac{F}{(1+y)^T} with T=14T = \tfrac14.

โœ… Correct! 100(1.0023)1/4โ‰ˆ99.94\dfrac{100}{(1.0023)^{1/4}} \approx 99.94: at a quarter-year to maturity the bill costs 6 cents less than its face value.
โŒ Not quite. 1001.0023โ‰ˆ99.77\dfrac{100}{1.0023} \approx 99.77 discounts for a full year. The bill matures in three months, so the exponent is T=14T = \tfrac14.
โŒ Check the units. One basis point is 0.01%0.01\%, so 2323 bp is 0.23%=0.00230.23\% = 0.0023, not 0.000230.00023.
โŒ Not quite. A price above the $100 face value would mean a negative yield. Divide by (1+y)T(1+y)^T; don't multiply.
โŒ Not quite. Use y=0.0023y = 0.0023 and T=14T = \tfrac14 in P=100(1+y)TP = \dfrac{100}{(1+y)^{T}}.
Show solution

2323 basis points is 0.23%0.23\%, so y=0.0023y = 0.0023, and three months is T=14T = \tfrac14 year:

P0,1/4=100(1.0023)1/4=1001.0005745โ‰ˆ99.94P_{0,1/4} = \frac{100}{(1.0023)^{1/4}} = \frac{100}{1.0005745} \approx 99.94

The bill costs about $99.94 per $100 of face value, 6 cents below face.

Problem 2 ยท Annualized, Not Quarterly

Given: from 1962 to 2002 the three-month bill yielded about 6%6\% on average, quoted as an annualized yield with annual compounding. Find what a bill yielding exactly 6%6\% earns over its three months.

โœ… Correct! (1.06)1/4โˆ’1โ‰ˆ1.467%(1.06)^{1/4} - 1 \approx 1.467\% over the quarter; four such quarters compound back to exactly 6%6\%.
โŒ Not quite. 6%6\% is the annualized quote. A three-month bill earns only a quarter-year's worth of it.
โŒ Close, butโ€ฆ 6%/4=1.5%6\% / 4 = 1.5\% ignores compounding: four quarters at 1.5%1.5\% give (1.015)4โˆ’1โ‰ˆ6.14%(1.015)^4 - 1 \approx 6.14\%, more than 6%6\%. Take the fourth root instead.
โŒ Not quite. (1.06)4โˆ’1โ‰ˆ26.25%(1.06)^4 - 1 \approx 26.25\% compounds 6%6\% over four years. For one quarter the exponent is 14\tfrac14.
โŒ Not quite. Convert with (1+y)1/4โˆ’1(1+y)^{1/4} - 1.
Show solution

A quoted yield is annualized: one year at yy grows $1 to 1+y1+y. One quarter is a quarter of the year, so

(1.06)1/4โˆ’1โ‰ˆ1.014674โˆ’1โ‰ˆ1.467%(1.06)^{1/4} - 1 \approx 1.014674 - 1 \approx 1.467\%

Check: (1.014674)4โ‰ˆ1.06(1.014674)^4 \approx 1.06. By the same step the video's 4%4\% is about 0.985%0.985\% a quarter, just under 1%1\%.

Problem 3 ยท The Day of the Guarantee

Given: on Thursday 18 September 2008 the three-month bill yielded 2323 basis points; on Friday 19 September, the day the Treasury announced its guarantee for money funds, it yielded 9999 basis points. Per $100 of face value, find the 19 September price and how far the price fell over the day.

Price on 19 September?

Fall in price from 18 to 19 September?

โœ… Correct! The yield rose 7676 bp and the price fell 19 cents per $100, about a quarter of 0.760.76, because the bill has only a quarter-year left to run.
โŒ Not quite. 1001.0099โ‰ˆ99.02\dfrac{100}{1.0099} \approx 99.02 discounts for a whole year; use T=14T = \tfrac14.
โŒ Not quite. 100โˆ’0.99100 - 0.99 treats the annualized yield as dollars taken off the price. The price is 100(1.0099)1/4\dfrac{100}{(1.0099)^{1/4}}.
โŒ Not quite. 99.9499.94 is the 18 September price at 2323 bp. The yield rose, so the price fell below it.
โŒ Check the price. P=100(1.0099)1/4P = \dfrac{100}{(1.0099)^{1/4}}.
โŒ Not quite. 99โˆ’23=7699 - 23 = 76 bp is the change in the annualized yield, not in the price. Subtract the two prices.
โŒ Not quite. That is one day's gap between price and the $100 face value (what the bill earns to maturity). The fall is the 18 September price minus the 19 September price.
โŒ Check the difference. Subtract the 19 September price from the 18 September price.
Show solution

18 September (y=0.0023y = 0.0023): 100(1.0023)1/4โ‰ˆ99.94\dfrac{100}{(1.0023)^{1/4}} \approx 99.94.

19 September (y=0.0099y = 0.0099):

100(1.0099)1/4=1001.0024659โ‰ˆ99.75\frac{100}{(1.0099)^{1/4}} = \frac{100}{1.0024659} \approx 99.75

Fall in price: 99.94โˆ’99.75=0.1999.94 - 99.75 = 0.19 per $100 of face value.

The video warns that the asset-purchase plan and the short-selling ban came the same day, so this jump cannot be credited to the guarantee alone.

Problem 4 ยท What a Long Treasury Risks

Given: a 30-year Treasury bond pays $1,000 at maturity. For illustration, suppose prices rise 3%3\% a year for all 30 years.

In today's goods, the $1,000 buys about

Which risk does the holder bear?

โœ… Correct! The $1,000 is certain in nominal terms, but at 3%3\% inflation it buys only about $412 of today's goods; that erosion is the risk, and why a rising 30-year yield reads as an inflation premium.
โŒ Not quite. $1,000 is the nominal payment, which is certain. The question asks what it will buy after 30 years of 3%3\% inflation.
โŒ Not quite. 1000(1โˆ’30ร—0.03)=1001000(1 - 30 \times 0.03) = 100 subtracts 3%3\% of the original value each year. Inflation compounds: divide by (1.03)30(1.03)^{30}.
โŒ Close, butโ€ฆ 1000ร—(0.97)30โ‰ˆ4011000 \times (0.97)^{30} \approx 401 uses 1โˆ’ฯ€1 - \pi as if it were 11+ฯ€\dfrac{1}{1+\pi}. The exact factor is 1(1.03)30\dfrac{1}{(1.03)^{30}}.
โŒ Check the purchasing power. Compute 1000(1.03)30\dfrac{1000}{(1.03)^{30}}.
โŒ Not quite. The United States issues the dollar and can always create dollars to pay; in nominal terms, as far as anyone knows, there is no default risk.
โŒ Not quite. No default risk is not no risk: the bond pays dollars, and what those dollars buy is uncertain.
โŒ Not quite. That was the risk inside prime money funds. A Treasury is an IOU from the government that issues the dollar, not company paper; its risk is what its dollars will buy.
โŒ Check the risk. A nominal bond promises dollars, not goods.
Show solution

Prices rise by the factor (1.03)30(1.03)^{30} over 30 years, so the $1,000 buys what

1000(1.03)30=10002.4273โ‰ˆ411.99\frac{1000}{(1.03)^{30}} = \frac{1000}{2.4273} \approx 411.99

dollars buy today, about $412. The payment itself carries no nominal default risk; the risk is inflation, and, if the bond is sold before maturity, changes in interest rates.

Solved: 0 / 4