Mathematical-Reasoning ยท Unit 24 ยท Video 2 ยท Interactive Practice

Reversing Every Arrow: The Function That Undoes a Bijection

IKey Formulas

StatementMeaning
f(a)=r,ย f(b)=p,ย f(c)=s,ย f(d)=qf(a) = r,\ f(b) = p,\ f(c) = s,\ f(d) = qThe video's bijection f:{a,b,c,d}โ†’{p,q,r,s}f : \{a, b, c, d\} \to \{p, q, r, s\}
g(p)=b,ย g(q)=d,ย g(r)=a,ย g(s)=cg(p) = b,\ g(q) = d,\ g(r) = a,\ g(s) = cThe reversed arrows define g:Bโ†’Ag : B \to A; g(y)g(y) is where the arrow of ff into yy started
(gโˆ˜f)(x)=x(g \circ f)(x) = x for all xโˆˆAx \in Agโˆ˜fg \circ f is the identity function on AA
(fโˆ˜g)(y)=y(f \circ g)(y) = y for all yโˆˆBy \in Bfโˆ˜gf \circ g is the identity function on BB

Key Insight: Surjectivity gives every element of BB at least one arrow to reverse; injectivity makes it at most one. At least one and at most one is exactly one, so the reversed arrows form a function.

IIWhen Do the Reversed Arrows Form a Function?

Each element of BB sends out one reversed arrow for every arrow of ff it received.

IIIOut and Back Again

Following an arrow of ff and then the reversed arrow of gg returns every element to where it started.

IVQuiz Questions

Problem 1 ยท Reading a Reversed Arrow

Given: the bijection f:{1,2,3}โ†’{u,v,w}f : \{1, 2, 3\} \to \{u, v, w\} with f(1)=wf(1) = w, f(2)=uf(2) = u, f(3)=vf(3) = v, and gg the function defined by the reversed arrows. What is g(u)g(u)?

โœ… Correct! The arrow of ff into uu starts at 22, so the reversed arrow from uu ends at 22.
โŒ That reads the list by position. uu is the output of 22, not of 11: f(2)=uf(2) = u.
โŒ Wrong set. gg goes from {u,v,w}\{u, v, w\} back to {1,2,3}\{1, 2, 3\}, so its outputs are numbers.
โŒ Not quite. Find the element of {1,2,3}\{1, 2, 3\} whose arrow lands on uu.
Show solution

g(u)g(u) is the start of the arrow of ff that ends at uu. Since f(2)=uf(2) = u, the reversed arrow runs from uu to 22, so g(u)=2g(u) = 2. Likewise g(v)=3g(v) = 3 and g(w)=1g(w) = 1.

Problem 2 ยท Reversing a Non-Bijection

Given: f:{a,b,c}โ†’{p,q,r}f : \{a, b, c\} \to \{p, q, r\} with f(a)=pf(a) = p, f(b)=pf(b) = p, f(c)=qf(c) = q. Do the reversed arrows define a function from {p,q,r}\{p, q, r\} to {a,b,c}\{a, b, c\}?

โœ… Correct! ff is not an injection (aa and bb share pp) and not a surjection (rr is missed), and each failure breaks the reversed arrows separately.
โŒ That is why ff is a function. The reversed arrows start in {p,q,r}\{p, q, r\}, so it is those elements that need exactly one arrow each.
โŒ Only half the story. There are two separate failures here, not one.
Show solution

The reversed arrows are pโ†’ap \to a, pโ†’bp \to b and qโ†’cq \to c.

  • pp sends out two arrows (to aa and to bb), because two arrows of ff landed on pp: ff is not an injection.
  • rr sends out none, because no arrow of ff landed on rr: ff is not a surjection.

A function from {p,q,r}\{p, q, r\} needs exactly one arrow out of each element, so both pp and rr fail.

Problem 3 ยท The Other Composite

Given: the video's f(a)=rf(a) = r, f(b)=pf(b) = p, f(c)=sf(c) = s, f(d)=qf(d) = q and its reversed-arrow function gg. Which statement about fโˆ˜gf \circ g is correct?

โœ… Correct! gg acts first and takes BB to AA; then ff takes AA back to BB. And f(g(q))=f(d)=qf(g(q)) = f(d) = q.
โŒ Check the domain. In fโˆ˜gf \circ g the function gg acts first, so the inputs are elements of BB; qq is not even in AA.
โŒ That stops halfway. g(q)=dg(q) = d is only the first step; ff still has to act on dd.
โŒ Not quite. Apply gg first, then ff: f(g(q))=f(d)f(g(q)) = f(d).
Show solution

fโˆ˜gf \circ g means "gg first, then ff". Since g:Bโ†’Ag : B \to A and f:Aโ†’Bf : A \to B, the composite goes from BB to BB. At qq:

(fโˆ˜g)(q)=f(g(q))=f(d)=q.(f \circ g)(q) = f\big(g(q)\big) = f(d) = q.

The same happens at every yโˆˆBy \in B, so fโˆ˜gf \circ g is the identity function on BB.

Problem 4 ยท What Reversal Requires

Given: finite sets AA, BB and a function f:Aโ†’Bf : A \to B whose reversed arrows define a function from BB to AA. Which statement must be true?

โœ… Correct! Every element of BB received exactly one arrow, so ff is onto and one-to-one, and the arrows pair the elements of AA and BB off one for one.
โŒ A missed element breaks it. If some yโˆˆBy \in B received no arrow, then yy has no reversed arrow, so it has no output.
โŒ A shared output breaks it. If two arrows land on yy, then yy sends out two reversed arrows.
โŒ Not quite. Count arrows: each element of BB must send out exactly one reversed arrow.
Show solution

Reversed arrows define a function from BB to AA exactly when each yโˆˆBy \in B sends out exactly one of them, that is, exactly one arrow of ff lands on each yy.

  • At least one arrow on each yy: ff is a surjection.
  • At most one arrow on each yy: ff is an injection.

So ff is a bijection. Its arrows match each element of AA with a different element of BB and use all of BB, so the two sets have the same number of elements.

Solved: 0 / 4