Is the cycloid's bottom point a corner, a smooth dip, or a cusp, and why can't first-order approximations decide?
Loading…
Four candidate shapes for the cycloid's bottom point
Sketch the four candidates (a corner with finite left and right slopes, a smooth horizontal tangent, a small loop, a vertical tangent) and record that the formulas, not the picture, decide.
The failed first-order guess and the next Taylor terms
With , show that and turn , into and , then use the Taylor formula through to derive and .
The slope ratio and the vertical tangent
Substitute to get and , compare their sizes, let in , and state the result: infinite slope, a cusp with a vertical tangent, motion straight down and back up.