Why do firms still lean on a payback cutoff when it adds dollars across dates and ignores everything after the cutoff?
Loading…
NPV dominates, yet the alternatives persist
Name the three alternatives (payback, IRR, profitability index), record that NPV, or APV once adjustments are made, dominates them, and note inertia and career risk as what keeps them in use.
The payback rule
Define payback as the minimum integer meeting this condition, state the accept rule and the rule for mutually exclusive projects, and work one small example of your own.
Discounted payback and the two flaws
Record that payback adds cash flows from different dates and ignores flows after , write the discounted payback condition, and show with an example that it repairs only the first flaw.
Three partial rationales for payback
Record forecast uncertainty, liquidity and level cash flows, and for each state where the concern properly belongs: the discount rates, the term structure, or the narrow case of comparable risk.